Hydrocarbon Processing Copying and distributing are prohibited without permission of the publisher
Email a friend
  • Please enter a maximum of 5 recipients. Use ; to separate more than one email address.

US Senate kills latest bid to speed approval of Keystone oil pipeline

03.09.2012  | 

The US Senate defeated an attempt by Republican lawmakers to grant congressional approval for the construction of a new oil pipeline, after the White House confirmed that President Barack Obama personally called senators to persuade them to reject it. Republicans were trying to override Obama's objection.



The US Senate on Thursday defeated an attempt by Republican lawmakers to grant congressional approval for the construction of a new oil pipeline, after the White House confirmed that President Barack Obama personally called senators to persuade them to reject it.

The Senate voted 56 to 42 in favor of granting congressional approval of the so-called Keystone XL pipeline project, four votes short of the 60 required for the measure's passage.

Republican lawmakers were joined by 11 Democrats in voting for granting the approval.

Republicans were trying to override the objections of the Obama administration to the construction of the pipeline.

Obama had a role in corralling Democrats to reject the Republican proposal for Keystone, as the White House said he called lawmakers to convince them it was "irresponsible."

The Republican proposal would have cleared the way for construction of the pipeline to begin immediately.

The Republican plan is "irresponsible because it .. tries to legislate the approval of a pipeline for which there is not even a route," White House Press Secretary Jay Carney said Thursday.

Carney wouldn't say which lawmakers the president called.

The president rejected TransCanada Corp.'s application for the pipeline construction in January, but said the company could reapply once it changed its proposed route to address environmental concerns.

The pipeline would run from the oil sands in Alberta, Canada, through the US to refineries on the Gulf Coast.

Last month, the administration granted approval to the construction of the southern portion of the pipeline. TransCanada said it is likely to submit a new application for the rest of the route.

The Republican measure would have circumvented this process and allow construction to begin immediately.

Sen. John Hoeven (R., N.D.) led the charge for Republicans on the matter.

"My amendment provides that the Keystone pipeline project will move forward, authorized by Congress," he said on the Senate floor before the vote, the latest attempt by congressional Republicans to force the administration's hand on the issue.

It was one of a number of amendment votes on a wider transportation bill. Like the Keystone vote, many of the votes on Thursday afternoon were unrelated to the underlying bill.

The legislation would extend for two years the federal funding formula for road, bridge and other transportation public works construction and repairs projects.

Some version of the legislation must be passed before the end of March when a temporary funding measure expires.

The Senate also defeated an alternative pipeline measure offered up by Senate Democrats. It would have dictated that none of the oil or natural gas that travels along the pipeline could be exported from the US, and that 100% of the building materials used in its construction are sourced from US companies.

That amendment was essentially a poison pill designed to ensure the defeat of the Republican amendment.

Lawmakers also defeated an attempt by Republicans to delay Environmental Protection Agency rules that will require large industrial firms to install greater pollution controls on their boilers and incinerators to reduce mercury, soot and other toxic emissions.

The issue has become hotly contested as GOP lawmakers have routinely held up it as an example of regulatory overreach by the Obama administration.

Dow Jones Newswires

Have your say
  • All comments are subject to editorial review.
    All fields are compulsory.

George H

Another 1,200 miles of pipe is not a problem. How many spills are we hearing about, pollution issues, etc, from the existing 600K plus of pipe moving hydrocarbons in the US?

George H

Well, Pres O will be in Cushing OK (3-22-12). Wonder how he will spin the locked up inventory as Big Oil is the problem? This oil wouldn't be stuck if the pipeline he rejects was alloed to proceed. As it is I understand the portion from Cushing to Tx will be constructed.

Bobby Johnson

It appears that our current U.S. President intends to handicap our economy in every way that he can devise. This is treachery at its worse. There are two ways to enslave people – by the sword or by debt. Debt is will be according to our President. It appears that we will now be increasing our imports of middle eastern oil instead of oil from one of our friendly allies.


The Wyden Amendment makes sense. If we are risking an oil spill on our homeland from the Keystone pipeline, then we should insist that all the oil it transports stays here.
And that the pipeline should be built and maintained by American workers -- with American made materials.
Otherwise, we would be relegating our land to a 30 year stepping stone for Canada to transport its dirty oil to foreign markets.
Indeed, the Wyden Amendment should be used as a model for all offshore and public land drilling. If our country incurs the long term risk of an oil spill, then it should also get the maximum benefit.
The "free market" will have to take a back seat on this one.
Our environment ain't free -- even to the free market.

Related articles


Sign-up for the Free Daily HP Enewsletter!

Boxscore Database

A searchable database of project activity in the global hydrocarbon processing industry


Is 2016 the peak for US gasoline demand?




View previous results

Popular Searches

Please read our Term and Conditions and Privacy Policy before using the site. All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws.
© 2016 Hydrocarbon Processing. © 2016 Gulf Publishing Company.