By MATHEW CARR
Europes backfiring climate and energy
policies are adding to high natural gas
costs and holding back
Dow Chemical's investment in the region, said the
companys director of global climate change policy.
European Union proposals to limit the amount of free emission
permits in its cap-and-trade program boost industry costs,
and are one reason Dow and other chemical makers limited refining
in the region for the
past 12 years, Russel Mills said by phone from Zurich on Dec.
That compares with the Midland, Michigan-based companys
$4 billion of US investment planned for the next four years,
Dow, the biggest US chemical maker, joined companies
including ExxonMobil in a Dutch court challenge to the
European Commissions decision to reduce the pollution
rights it hands out to factories, Mills said. Manufacturers
may seek compensation of about 4 billion euros ($5.5 billion)
in total for the lost free permits, according to Utility
Support Group, an adviser to some Dutch chemical factories on
It really is a slap in the face for
manufacturers, Mills said. Maybe they
underestimate the efficiency with which markets can work if
they are allowed to work.
Commission spokesman Isaac Valero-Ladron in Brussels declined
to comment when reached by e-mail.
The EU is seeking to curb a surplus of permits in its carbon
market that pushed prices to a record low and eroded the
incentive for companies to invest in emission-reducing
technologies. The commission decided in September to lower
the handout of free allowances to factories by 12% in the
eight years through 2020.
Under the blocs emissions trading system, permits to
emit carbon dioxide are mostly allocated for free to
factories, which must surrender enough to match their CO2
output or pay fines. Power companies must pay for their
allowances. Mills and Utility Support Group argue the
commission isnt giving enough free carbon rights for
manufacturers heat generation and waste-gas production.
European gas prices are already relatively high, with the
cost of the fuel in the UK more than twice the level in the
US. BASF in Germany, India
s Tata Chemicals and
Lotte Chemical of South Korea shut plants in Britain this
ExxonMobils Dutch unit is also appealing against the
commission decision to cut free allowances, Richard Scrase, a
Leatherhead, England-based spokesman for the company, said
Dec. 12. The move was a standard procedure to preserve
our rights in anticipation of more data transparency from the
EU commission on its calculation of free ETS
allowances, he said.
Europes adoption of renewable energy subsidies,
Germanys shift from nuclear power and the EUs
effort to support carbon prices are all adding to industry
costs, Dows Mills said.
Nations embracing carbon markets need to make it a low-
cost club not a high-cost club, he said.
EU carbon permits for December 2014 dropped 0.8% on Monday to
4.88 euros a metric ton on ICE Futures Europe in London. The
benchmark contract was as high as 31 euros a ton in 2006.